HIMIWAY Big Dog vs HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST

Where each one wins

• HIMIWAY Big Dog is 13.1 kg lighter.
• HIMIWAY Big Dog is 13 km/h faster.
• HIMIWAY Big Dog is 30 Nm more torque.
• HIMIWAY Big Dog is 7 km further on range.

The HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST does not lead on a single measured axis here. That does not make it the wrong bike, but it does mean the HIMIWAY Big Dog is the one to justify not buying.

What each one costs to own

Over 5 years the HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST costs about 980 EUR less to own, once purchase, charging, servicing, a battery replacement where one is due, and resale are all counted.

That figure moves mostly on the battery. The HIMIWAY Big Dog covers about 38,400 km before its pack is due for replacement; the HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST, about 38,400 km. Ride less than that and the replacement never enters the sum.

Run these numbers on your own mileage

Which one to buy

• Pick the HIMIWAY Big Dog if you ride to the edge of the battery and dislike planning around it.
• Pick the HIMIWAY Big Dog if you carry the bike up steps, onto a train, or into a flat.
• Pick the HIMIWAY Big Dog if your route has real hills, or you carry cargo or a passenger.
• Pick the HIMIWAY Big Dog if your commute has fast stretches where the assist cutting out matters.
• Pick the HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST if the five-year total is what you are optimising.

Verdict

On the measured axes the HIMIWAY D5 PRO ST is the better buy, and the HIMIWAY Big Dog needs a reason of its own: a colour, a frame, a shop you trust, a price that moves. None of those are in our numbers, and all of them are legitimate.

Range here is an estimate under one reference ride, not a measurement. Yours will differ with terrain, weight, tyres and weather, which is what the range calculator is for.